Review: What They Always Tell Us

What They Always Tell Us

Title: What They Always Tell Us
Author: Martin Wilson
Published: August 12th 2008 by Delacorte Books for Young Readers
Purchase: Book Depository | Amazon
James and Alex have barely anything in common anymore—least of all their experiences in high school, where James is a popular senior and Alex is suddenly an outcast. But at home, there is Henry, the precocious 10-year-old across the street, who eagerly befriends them both. And when Alex takes up running, there is James’s friend Nathen, who unites the brothers in moving and unexpected ways.

What They Always Tell Us is a character driven book exploring the lives of two brothers, Alex and James. It’s a quiet and simple book but I expected more from it so I was underwhelmed by the story.

Martin Wilson’s writing was easy to get lost into, I fell into that lazy, slow town Alex and James resided in and their individual frustrations were easy to identify with. James and Alex were both very different. James was the popular guy who wanted to escape the small town he was stuck in, he was angry, a coward and insecure though he always put up an-everything-is-fine front. Alex was avoided, isolated, vulnerable and he was always in James’s shadow.

I adored both Alex and James, it was very enjoyable reading from each of their POV. I liked the way the characters developed, James facing the issues he avoided and Alex’s quiet determination to want and to be happy. Although I felt like the supporting characters fell a bit flat and were undeveloped, they played essential roles. Each character introduced had some part in bringing Alex and James together. Henry was the biggest mystery, I felt like he was a vessel used to bring these two brothers together as his appearances were so sparse but my heart also hurt for him in those short moments he was present.

Coming of age defines this book, it was about self discovery and acceptance through the quiet happenings and encounters in their lives, not only for Alex and James, but the supporting characters as well. I liked that the themes of this book weren’t pigeonholed into one focal point but was spread across the development of James and Alex, their tentative friendships with other characters and their experiences throughout the book. It was bittersweet and painful and moving, everything a contemporary should be but it just felt average. It was a solid book but nothing I hadn’t come across before though the LGBT theme was the only aspect that set it apart from other books as it was handled so well here.

There were so many good things about this book but I was still left feeling unsatisfied. I recommend this book if you’re looking for a quick, relaxing, realistic story or you’re a fan of LGBT or coming of age.

3 Stars

6 thoughts on “Review: What They Always Tell Us”

  1. brandileigh2003

    Alex and James sound great, and I like the sound of this one. I haven’t heard of it so really appreciate the review.
    Brandi @ Blkosiner’s Book Blog

  2. Dianna (Stories After Twelve)

    I remember I wanted to pick this up some months ago but for some reasons I never did. I think I should give a try soon. Your review thoroughly describes the book and from what I read I believe I would like this, but probably would be left unsatisfied, too. I absolutely love this review, Isa! : )

  3. Cayce

    I have What They Always Tell Us on my tbr, but haven’t gotten to it yet. But reading your review made me want to meet Alex, James and Henry. So I might consider moving it up on the list.

    Thanks for the review, Isa! :)

  4. Rachel @ Unforgettable Books

    Your blog design is pretty!

    Wonderful review! I always love coming of age stories too. This sounds like a good book with interesting main characters. Flawed characters are the best!

  5. Ashley @ Book Labyrinth

    Hmmm, sounds like a bit too slow of a read for me, perhaps, especially since you say you were left unsatisfied.

    Thanks for the review. =)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *